Min Price $400$500$600$700$800$900$1000$1100$1200$1300$1400$1500$1600$1700$1800$1900$2000$2200$2400$2500$2600$2800$3000$3200$3400$3500$3600$3800$4000$4200$4400$4500$4600$4800$5000$7500$10000$15000 to Max Price $400$500$600$700$800$900$1000$1100$1200$1300$1400$1500$1600$1700$1800$1900$2000$2200$2400$2500$2600$2800$3000$3200$3400$3500$3600$3800$4000$4200$4400$4500$4600$4800$5000$7500$10000$15000 All Beds 1+2+3+4+5+ All Baths 1+2+3+4+5+ 5 recently rented properties in Pine Island, NY 614 County Route 1 #2, Pine Island, NY 10969 Recently rented $750 1 bath400 sqft View details 12 Pulaski Hwy, Pine Island, NY 10969 Recently rented $775 Multi-Family Home 1 bed1 bath700 sqft View details 8 Schoolhouse Rd #b, Pine Island, NY 10969 Recently rented $1,500 3 beds1 bath1275 sqft View details 18 Stage Rd, Pine Island, NY 10969 Recently rented $2,300 Single Family 3 beds2 baths1426 sqft View details 30 Sunnyside Ln, Pine Island, NY 10969 Recently rented $2,100 Single Family Residential 3 beds2 baths1624 sqft View details